Skip to main content
Back to Trader Intelligence
Market Cycle Commentary•15 min read

I Made 300% and Felt Robbed: Managing a 10 Percent Drawdown and the Money You Missed

James•

On November 4, I bought SPY puts for a short-term swing short. It was the kind of setup I wait weeks for, and I had the patience to wait. The next day, I sold my SPY 765 puts for a gain of about 300 percent. Later that day, I watched those puts run past 1,000 percent relative to my entry.

I had been right, and I had been paid, and I felt robbed.

I haven't looked at what those puts are worth now. That feeling is the reason this post exists. The market didn't take money from me on that exit. But the way I reacted to it affected what I did for the next two weeks.

This isn't a lesson in holding every winner longer. It's about keeping a trade you have already closed from making the decisions on your next one.

The short version

  • A profitable exit isn't a mistake just because the position kept running. Judge it against the plan and information you had at the time.
  • Wider markets call for a fresh risk calculation, not an automatic doubling of size or stop distance.
  • The money you didn't make is a profit and loss statement that doesn't exist. Audit it before it becomes a trade.
  • Write your limits while you're calm. Don't invent them with a position open and your pulse up.

What happened: seven red sessions, more than 10 percent off the high

On Friday, November 20, 2026, Fortune reported that the S&P 500 fell 3.59 percent to 6,918.45, closing more than 10 percent below its October 6 record close. The Nasdaq Composite had given back its gains for the year.

Friday was the S&P's seventh consecutive losing session, according to that report. The drawdown was measured from the October record, not the start of the week, and it describes the index, not my account.

The sequence matters more than a single explanation:

  • October 28: The Federal Reserve held its target range at 3.75 to 4 percent in a 10-to-2 vote. The two dissenters preferred a quarter-point increase.
  • November 4: The S&P rose 1.58 percent after the midterms, while the Dow gained 1,569 points, or 3 percent, according to CNN's report carried by WTTW.
  • November 5: The rally reversed. Fortune's afternoon report described the S&P down about 3.8 percent and the Nasdaq down about 5.2 percent. Those were intraday figures, not closing returns.
  • November 12: Nvidia announced Jensen Huang's resignation and appointed CFO Colette Kress interim CEO. The announcement did not give a reason for his departure.
  • November 20: The selling left both the S&P and the Dow in correction territory. Fortune reported that Nvidia, Micron, Broadcom, and AMD each fell roughly 12 to 14 percent.

Those events shared a calendar. That doesn't tell us exactly how much of the decline each caused. Rates, earnings expectations, positioning, and company news were being repriced together.

The election rally wasn't a verdict

Wednesday's rally and Thursday's reversal are a useful warning about headline trading. CNN described investors welcoming the prospect of divided government while worrying about restrictions on data-center construction. Both interpretations were already present on Wednesday. By Thursday, the selling had spread.

It is tempting to say the election caused one move and then caused its opposite. That's more certainty than the evidence gives us. What we can observe is that the first reaction didn't settle the direction.

We made the same practical point in what the tariff headlines revealed about your edge: a plausible explanation isn't an entry signal. It still needs a setup and an invalidation point.

The IPO and the gain you couldn't necessarily keep

Anthropic's November 19 debut offers another way to see the money-missed problem. FourWeekMBA's day-one recap, citing Nasdaq closing data and CNBC's opening-price report, put the offer price at $83, the first trade at $111.50, and the close at $97.17.

On those figures, the stock finished about 17.1 percent above the offer price but 12.9 percent below the opening trade. A buyer at $111.50 who held to the close had a very different day from an investor allocated shares at $83.

That's the part relevant here. Watching a reported IPO gain doesn't mean the same gain was available at your entry price. The move you envy from the sidelines isn't always one you could have kept.

Whether the offering contributed to the broader selloff is a separate causal claim. The price comparison doesn't establish it, and this trading lesson doesn't need it.

What nobody knows

Fortune's November 20 report captured the disagreement. BNP Paribas's Benedicte Lowe described panic selling. Deutsche Bank's Binky Chadha described an oversold market with strong growth and earnings. At midday, Luke Lango argued that money was leaving tech rather than the whole market, while the Dow and equal-weight S&P were still higher.

Those were interpretations at particular moments, not interchangeable closing observations. None supplied a reliable entry, stop, or position size.

There's room to study the economy and still admit that the next move is uncertain. The question for my account is whether my next trade has a reason that stands on its own.

How a winning trade affected the next two weeks

After selling, I went looking for opinions. I read trader commentary and started talking myself out of the short thesis that had just paid me. I flipped my view and began buying the dip. A bounce rewarded that change long enough for me to trust it. When the selling intensified on November 19 and 20, I was on the wrong side.

Looking back, I can see how regret influenced that sequence. I wanted to stop feeling bad about the exit. Commentary gave me a different story to follow, and I let that story influence my direction and size.

That doesn't mean every losing trade came from one feeling, or that staying short would necessarily have worked. It means I have to review more than the chart. I have to review why I changed my mind.

A new thesis can be legitimate. The useful question is whether I would have taken the same trade if the previous one had never happened.

Was the exit wrong, or did it just feel wrong afterward?

A 300 percent gain followed by a larger move makes an easy story: I sold too early. It doesn't settle whether I made a poor decision.

If the exit followed a tested plan, later price action doesn't retroactively turn it into a rule violation. If I abandoned the plan because I couldn't tolerate watching an open gain fluctuate, that's a different problem. The chart alone can't tell me which happened.

In his 1975 research on hindsight bias, Baruch Fischhoff found that knowing an outcome changed people's judgments of how likely it had been. They were largely unaware of that influence. Applied to a trade review, the warning is straightforward: knowing where price went can make holding look easier than it actually was.

Hersh Shefrin and Meir Statman examined the tendency to sell winners and hold losers in their 1985 paper on the disposition effect. That research gives us a pattern to investigate, not a diagnosis to attach to every profitable exit.

My review needs the entry rationale, the intended exit, the information available then, and what I actually did. Not just the best price I could have received with hindsight.

Recalculate risk before taking another position

A wider daily range is a reason to reassess a setup. It doesn't automatically double the dollar risk of every position, and it doesn't mean every stop should be twice as wide.

For a simple futures example, planned price risk is stop distance in points multiplied by dollars per point and the number of contracts. That calculation still needs room for costs and adverse execution.

Hypothetical example: CME specifies $50 per index point for one E-mini S&P 500 futures contract. A six-point stop represents $300 of price risk on one ES contract before fees and slippage. If a valid setup instead requires a twelve-point stop, one ES represents $600.

You can't trade half an ES contract. CME's Micro E-mini contracts are one-tenth the size. Five MES contracts at $5 per point with a twelve-point stop represent $300 of price risk before costs. That's a sizing illustration, not a recommendation to take the trade. If the smallest suitable position exceeds your budget, passing remains an option.

Planned risk is not a guaranteed maximum loss. Execution depends on the instrument, order type, liquidity, and broker or exchange rules. FINRA's guidance on stock stop orders explains the distinction clearly: a stop price is not a guaranteed execution price, while a stop-limit order can remain unfilled.

The same discipline applies to the trade that started this story. An option position isn't interchangeable with a futures position; its value also responds to time and implied volatility. Don't transplant the ES arithmetic into a SPY option trade.

Being comfortable with a position isn't enough to make it sensible. The risk calculation and the setup must work first. Then ask whether you can execute the plan without improvising. That's the practical distinction behind position sizing is a feeling problem.

Respect the structure and check the calendar

A correction is not, by itself, a buy signal. Nor does a run of red sessions make the next short safe. Buying because price is lower and selling because you missed the decline can both be decisions about discomfort rather than a setup.

The next scheduled FOMC meeting is December 8 and 9. Before that, NYSE markets are closed for Thanksgiving on November 26, with a 1 p.m. Eastern early close for the core equities session on November 27. Eligible options have a 1:15 p.m. close. Futures have their own product-specific schedules; don't apply stock-market hours to ES.

Check the schedule and your instrument's conditions before trading. A holiday session can have different liquidity and spreads. Decide whether it belongs in your plan before the open, not after an uncomfortable fill.

I also hold a long-term equity book alongside the day-trading account. It needs its own review rules and time horizon. Decide what warrants a review and whether additions follow a schedule or predefined criteria. An intraday feeling shouldn't silently become the investment policy for a different account.

The reset I should have used

These are the rules I would put around the next regretted exit. They are guardrails for the behavior I'm describing, not universal trading rules or a promise of better returns.

  1. Pause new positions for at least 24 hours after an exit that leaves me wanting to make up for it. Then reassess before returning. I can update my market view during the pause; I don't have to act on it. Existing positions still need their planned risk management.
  2. Stop reading trader commentary while I'm looking for emotional relief. Read my own entry and exit notes first. Outside analysis can be useful, but not when I'm shopping for permission.
  3. Review the exit method outside market hours. A partial exit is one approach to test, not an automatic improvement. It can reduce participation in a continuing move, add costs, and leave the remainder exposed to reversal. Decide whether it fits the strategy before the next trade, not because one winner kept running.

The pause is not a commitment to stay bearish or bullish. It's a commitment to stop opening positions until I can explain the next one without referring to what I wish the last one had earned.

The money you didn't make

There are several ways to feel left out of the same market. You may have missed the rally into the high, missed the short on the way down, or caught a winner and then watched it keep going without you. Mine was that third version.

Each invites a comparison with a trade that never existed in your account. In the imagined version, the entry is excellent, the size is right, and you hold through every bounce. The doubt and adverse movement disappear from the replay.

That comparison can hurt. It doesn't prove that a missed move hurts everyone more than a real loss, or that every change of market view is revenge trading. The useful question is narrower: am I evaluating an opportunity, or trying to stop feeling bad about the last one?

The fix isn't to feel nothing. It's to notice when the feeling is choosing the trade.

The missed-move audit

Before regret turns into an order, give it a page in the journal.

  1. Write the move in one line. Name the instrument, the dates, and the part you think you missed. Separate your actual result from the hypothetical result you're comparing it with.
  2. Ask three questions. Did my written plan have a setup for this move? Would I realistically have held through the adverse moves along the way? What size could I have carried within my risk limits?
  3. Write a review action, or write “not my trade.” A review action might be to test an alternative exit on a larger sample. It isn't permission to change a live strategy because one chart now looks obvious.

If your plan had no entry, you didn't miss an executable trade under that plan. You saw a move. Whether the plan itself needs work is a separate question, answered with evidence rather than one afternoon of regret.

File the entry and return to it at your scheduled review, not every time you want to replay the trade. A journal that changes behavior should help you distinguish a disciplined pass from an avoided setup. It shouldn't become another screen for watching imaginary profits.

Don't chase the correction to repair the missed short

After a selloff, the urge to short can feel like finally getting the lesson. Sometimes it's just the same regret pointing in a new direction.

A late short is not automatically wrong. But “I should have been short earlier” isn't an entry criterion. The current setup needs its own location, invalidation point, and risk budget. A bounce can punish an unplanned short just as another leg down can punish an unplanned dip buy.

Nor does sitting out make the next trade safer. Feeling vindicated isn't evidence that you should increase size. As in the winning streak is the setup, a good outcome deserves a process review, not a larger allowance for the next idea.

The money I didn't make can't be spent. It also doesn't need to be recovered. My actual account is the one I have to protect.

Your Monday card

Use this as a starting point for your own written rules. Set the numbers and conditions before the session.

  • My daily loss limit is written in dollars, with a clear action if it's reached.
  • My limit on consecutive losing trades and my pause after a loss are defined.
  • My size matches the current setup, stop distance, and risk budget, with allowance for execution costs.
  • I've checked the economic calendar and the trading hours for my instrument.
  • If exit regret is driving an urge to trade, I pause new positions for at least 24 hours and reassess before returning.
  • I'm not using commentary to justify an emotionally chosen direction.
  • I can explain the next trade without mentioning the money I missed.

If you've already exceeded your limits, start with the drawdown recovery protocol, not a new opportunity to earn it back.

The question underneath it

When I look at the trade I closed, what bothers me more: the money I didn't earn, or the thought that I should have known?

The first invites a review of execution. The second can turn every new position into an attempt to prove something.

If that distinction is familiar, the TQ Assessment can help you reflect on your trading discipline and relationship with risk. The practical work continues in the Complete Calm Trading Method and Trade Calm. None of them can tell you where the next candle closes.

I made money on November 5. I still had something to learn from it. The lesson wasn't to catch every point. It was to stop letting the points I missed choose my next trade.

Sources and disclosure

Market reporting is attributed inline to Fortune, CNN via WTTW, and FourWeekMBA. The Fed decision and calendar, Nvidia's leadership announcement, NYSE holiday hours, and CME contract specifications link to the issuing organizations. The behavioral research and stock-order guidance are linked beside the claims they support. Sources were reviewed November 21, 2026. Intraday figures are identified as such; IPO percentage comparisons are calculated from the reported offer, opening, and closing prices.

The SPY trade and subsequent decisions are my personal account, not independently audited performance. The approximate percentage gain describes that option trade, not my account return or a result readers should expect. The later option value was not an executed sale. The futures sizing example is hypothetical.

Educational content only, not investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell a security or contract. Futures, options, and other leveraged instruments involve substantial risk of loss. Past performance does not indicate future results.

Related posts

The content on this platform is provided for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute financial advice, investment advice, or trading recommendations of any kind. TradeQuillo, LLC is not a registered investment adviser, broker-dealer, or financial planner. All trading involves substantial risk of loss. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Always consult a qualified financial professional before making investment decisions.

RISK DISCLOSURE: Trading any financial instrument involves substantial risk of loss and is not appropriate for all investors. You could lose all of your deposited funds, and with leveraged products you may be liable for losses beyond your initial deposit. Only risk capital, money you can afford to lose, should be used for trading. This educational content is not a solicitation or offer to buy or sell any security or financial instrument.

© 2026 TradeQuillo, LLC. All rights reserved.

We use cookies for authentication, security, and aggregate analytics. Non-essential cookies only load after you grant consent.